Genealogy

Read the article this discussion is about

Myth vs History

  1. pink101
  2. Darlene Vaillancourt
  3. PaFusion
  4. suemax

This archived discussion is "read only" due to the absence of an active Feature Writer/moderator for this topic.



Top
1.   Jan 12, 2007 6:05 AM

» pink101 - Family Trees


.
One of the things about family trees--when we begin to study our own--is that we can't always trust the hype some ancestor may have added.
.
For whatever reason, people cut and add others out of and into their genealogy. Makes you want to dig some body up and get a dna sample to make sure. happy
.
I was lucky in my family research. I inadvertently stumbled onto a lady who had done the entire line ever since the first member landed on this continent. When we visited her home, she had an entire wall 8' by 10' lined with loose ring note books complete with computer print outs of nearly every individual in her maternal and paternal lines. It's a really exciting way for me to learn American History--to trace my family's evolution according to the growth of the nation. Everyone should do it.
.

-- posted by pink101

Permalink Print Discussion Print Discussion Email Discussion Email Discussion Suite101: Myth vs History How to subscribe to feeds

Top
2.   Jan 13, 2007 6:26 AM

» Darlene Vaillancourt - Family Trees

In response to Family Trees posted by pink101:
That is very true. I hadn't even thought of "personal myths" when I wrote that article. Family stories and traditions are NOT facts, though they can give you a starting point when doing actual research.

I had the same luck. A cousin of mine did all the "leg-work" for our immediate family back for a number of generations. Gave me an excellent foundation to build on.

I agree that genealogy can be a wonderful way to learn about history on a very personal level. People stop being faceless names in a book when they are actual relatives.

Suite101
Darlene Vaillancourt
Contributing Writer for Suite101

Permalink Print Discussion Print Discussion Email Discussion Email Discussion Suite101: Myth vs History How to subscribe to feeds

Top
3.   Jun 1, 2007 12:12 AM

» PaFusion - Family histories and traditions


Traditions and family stories are interesting clues for doing research. Much of my ancestor's history is lost. I regretted not having stories in my family of pioneer wagon trains, handcarts, prospectors or bandits. Later a few bits of information were pieced together to reveal some of my great grandparent's history. Two aunts wrote what they could recall about my grandparents and that is a cherished treasure. But it took my daughter's resourcefulness to get me to write my personal history. For Christmas she and her children thought of questions they wanted me to write a few words about. There were about 50 topics that were written on small strips of paper, rolled and placed in a decorated yogurt cup. At the rate of about one topic a week I answered their queries and added a few other ideas I thought appropriate and by the end of the year I had a sizeable story of my life, interests and accomplishments. She told me it was hard to think of that many subjects and maybe that is partly why I hadn't written the story before. I have a hard time thinking of things to write about. As an example, What is your favorite..., What advice would you leave your grandchildren?, What do you remember about..., Who were your childhood friends? The next year she said now draw pictures to illustrate what you wrote.

-- posted by PaFusion

Permalink Print Discussion Print Discussion Email Discussion Email Discussion Suite101: Myth vs History How to subscribe to feeds

Top
4.   Nov 5, 2007 9:32 AM

» suemax - mythology and family history


Mythology has taken on an incorect meaning today; if you look at the Wikipedia site you will see that mythology is not a false story but a valid one explained in a manner that can be receuved only in this way.J R Tolkien said, "I have tried to modernize the myths and make them credible." Both as a mythmaker and as a philogist Tolkien knew the importance of mythology to language and culture. Myths develop a link with the past, A continuity that hleps people weather the present and look forward to the future. In an era of unprecidented change, the links to the past are stretched to the breaking point, and people without roots are likely to become, analogously,a people without brances or flowers. The roots of the past -mythology-are no longer acceptable in their traditional form and have to be reread in a contemporary, relevant mode."
I have been exploring the reasons why for some of us there is a tremendous amoutn of serendipity in doing family history work, and while I just came across this quote,while reading his bio,it seems to me to be pertinent to genealogy in some manner tht I don't quit grasp,yet. The ancient legends which he studied, were ways of present historical truths,and it may be tht these are somehow a part of our collecive consciousness of memory of ancient things. There must be an important role for valid myth in genealogy and family stories and connecting families with themselves and their pasts. Sue

-- posted by suemax

Permalink Print Discussion Print Discussion Email Discussion Email Discussion Suite101: Myth vs History How to subscribe to feeds

This archived discussion is "read only" due to the absence of an active Feature Writer/moderator for this topic.

Please follow the guidelines set forth in the Suite101 Posting Etiquette when adding to the discussion.